Home All Groups Group Topic Archive Search About
Author
15 Nov 2006 4:27 PM
Jordan
We have guests that come into the building that need Internet access so we
wanted to find some solution that:

1. Cover the whole 33,000 sq ft single floor building.
2. If it is multiple APs then be centrally managed.
3. Allow the quick creation of access accounts for the guests.
4. Expire the accounts automatically after a certain period (minutes, hours,
days)
5. Still allow or should I say "force" my internal users onto our network
while keeping the guests off our network.

The reason I want to force our internal users onto our network is because we
monitor and filter their access through and ISA Server which prevents them
from downloading programs, questionable content, etc.

Author
15 Nov 2006 5:12 PM
Michael
Quick analysis I would say you would need to look into getting multiple Cisco
Ap's along with using a tool like WCS system to control monitoring and
deployment. There are cheaper solutions but it depends on how much of
LOS(line of sight) you have in a large area like this.

Now for username management obviously depending on how many "guest" you have
comming in this could become very tedious and it also depends on where you
want them to authenticate on the domain or outside in a seperate DMZ safe
zone.

I would suggest unless you want to go the TACAS or RADIUS type
authentication is to setup a  type service where the guest have to fill out a
short form and authenticate to a seperate server all together. There are
opensource packages out there setup for a one disc cd boot of these type
systems along with controls on time, where they can go etc. It basically
breaks down to the server becomming a proxy to the guest users and allowing
only what you want and when you want.

Keeping this network seperate from any sort of production server on the
network or private would be your best option.

If you want some suggestions on this let me know but I need a little more
information on which direction you want to go.

Michael

Show quote
"Jordan" wrote:

> We have guests that come into the building that need Internet access so we
> wanted to find some solution that:
>
> 1. Cover the whole 33,000 sq ft single floor building.
> 2. If it is multiple APs then be centrally managed.
> 3. Allow the quick creation of access accounts for the guests.
> 4. Expire the accounts automatically after a certain period (minutes, hours,
> days)
> 5. Still allow or should I say "force" my internal users onto our network
> while keeping the guests off our network.
>
> The reason I want to force our internal users onto our network is because we
> monitor and filter their access through and ISA Server which prevents them
> from downloading programs, questionable content, etc.
>

>
>
>
Author
15 Nov 2006 5:26 PM
David Hettel
First I'd ask do we really need to cover the whole 33,000 sq ft building? Or
could they be directed to a number of areas within the building to access
the internet. If they do need access from the entire 33,000 square feet then
I believe you'll need wireless. I'm not at all sure you'll find a quick and
easy way to do what you want. I suggest that you read this newsgroup, you'll
soon see that for many wireless is not easy. As they are *guest* I'm
assuming that you don't control their hardware, so you'll need a wireless
solution that works with a large number of different hardware
configurations.

I'd suggest that you create a MAC address list for your hardware, and find a
wireless solution that supports denying access to certain MAC address. Use
your hardware MAC address list to keep your employees off the system.
Another option might be to give your employees hardware that does not
support the guest system hardware.  Your computers use 802.11a radios and
the guest system uses 802.11b/g radios.

Any system that is easy to setup for visitors will be also be easy for your
employees that so desire to gain access to IMHO. So make their be little
reason for your employees to want to gain access to it. Make it slow and
filtered as well.

--
David Hettel

Please post any reply as a follow-up message in the news group for everyone
to see.  I'm sorry, but I don't answer questions addressed directly to me in
E-mail or news groups.

Microsoft Most Valuable Professional Program
http://mvp.support.microsoft.com

DISCLAIMER: This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranty of any kind,
either expressed or implied, made in relation to the accuracy, reliability
or content of this post. The author shall not be liable for any direct,
indirect, incidental or consequential damages arising out of the use of, or
inability to use, information or opinions expressed in this post and confers
no rights.


Show quote
"Jordan" <n***@here.com> wrote in message
news:%232ntvLNCHHA.3396@TK2MSFTNGP02.phx.gbl...
> We have guests that come into the building that need Internet access so we
> wanted to find some solution that:
>
> 1. Cover the whole 33,000 sq ft single floor building.
> 2. If it is multiple APs then be centrally managed.
> 3. Allow the quick creation of access accounts for the guests.
> 4. Expire the accounts automatically after a certain period (minutes,
> hours, days)
> 5. Still allow or should I say "force" my internal users onto our network
> while keeping the guests off our network.
>
> The reason I want to force our internal users onto our network is because
> we monitor and filter their access through and ISA Server which prevents
> them from downloading programs, questionable content, etc.
>
>
>
>
Author
15 Nov 2006 9:50 PM
Don Grover
Easest way is to stick a seperate broadband connection in, different subnet
ect, that way you keep all seperate and can control access times independant
of internal lan.
May cost you $25 a month but management time sved would cover this cost.
Don


Show quote
"Jordan" <n***@here.com> wrote in message
news:%232ntvLNCHHA.3396@TK2MSFTNGP02.phx.gbl...
> We have guests that come into the building that need Internet access so we
> wanted to find some solution that:
>
> 1. Cover the whole 33,000 sq ft single floor building.
> 2. If it is multiple APs then be centrally managed.
> 3. Allow the quick creation of access accounts for the guests.
> 4. Expire the accounts automatically after a certain period (minutes,
> hours, days)
> 5. Still allow or should I say "force" my internal users onto our network
> while keeping the guests off our network.
>
> The reason I want to force our internal users onto our network is because
> we monitor and filter their access through and ISA Server which prevents
> them from downloading programs, questionable content, etc.
>
>
>
>
Author
16 Nov 2006 1:38 AM
Pavel A.
"Jordan" wrote:
> We have guests that come into the building that need Internet access so we
> wanted to find some solution that:
>
> 1. Cover the whole 33,000 sq ft single floor building.
> 2. If it is multiple APs then be centrally managed.
> 3. Allow the quick creation of access accounts for the guests.
> 4. Expire the accounts automatically after a certain period (minutes, hours,
> days)
> 5. Still allow or should I say "force" my internal users onto our network
> while keeping the guests off our network.

Use APs that have "dual personality" capability: such AP has two or
more SSIDs; for guest access you can configure a SSID with no security,
and for internal users - another SSID with proper security;
the AP then separates the traffic to a public internet router
or your internal LAN.

Guest accounts can be identified by MAC address and kicked off
after some time; maybe there even are APs wih this capabiluty.
Otherwise you can make a SNMP based utility for this.

> The reason I want to force our internal users onto our network is because we
> monitor and filter their access through and ISA Server which prevents them
> from downloading programs, questionable content, etc.

It is enough to inform the employees that connecting to the guest network
and downloading stuff from internet violates the company's IT policy.
You can't prohibit them from doing this by any _reasonable_ technical means.
( there are also _unreasonable_ means, which IMHO are too restrictive and
expensive.)

Regards,
--PA

AddThis Social Bookmark Button